
I recently ran two Instagram trial reels for a travel brand we work with. One got 11 views. The other got 567.
A trial reel is a reel Instagram shows to people who don't follow you yet, before your followers ever see it. That makes it a really good way to test, trial, and experiment with new ideas without any crazy risks. Here's what I tested, why one basically flopped, and how I'd use trial reels for your brand.
A trial reel is a normal Instagram Reel with one twist: Instagram shows it to non-followers first. It stays off your profile grid (the wall of posts people see when they land on your page) unless you choose to share it with everyone.
About 24 hours after you post, Instagram shows you how it's doing: views, likes, comments, and shares. If it does well, you can share it with your followers yourself, or set it to share automatically if it performs well based on its first 72 hours.
Honestly, this is my favourite part. If a trial reel does well, it can show up on your feed and your grid, and that's a huge asset. You end up with a video that's already proven itself with strangers, sitting right on your page. It's basically how Instagram rewards you for testing.
I like to think of it like a taste test at the grocery store. Strangers try it first, and if they like it, it goes on the shelf. (Quick note: you'll need a professional account, and the rules on who can use trial reels have changed a few times, so check your app.)
Honestly, I only got two tests in, so this is a tiny sample. But I'm glad the two videos were totally different, because it made the gap really easy to see.
The packing video won because it gave a stranger a reason to stay. It had a real person, the product in use, and text that told you what you'd learn in the first second or two. My teammate Brie said it's the same story on the main feed: lifestyle reels that show the product in use are always our top performers.
Just for context, though: because the two videos were so different, so I can't say for sure what made the difference yet. SocialKit's trial reels guide suggests testing one thing at a time (the hook, the format, the topic, or the caption) and says that over four to six trials you'll have a clear pattern. That's the plan for our next round.
Trial reels work best when you're trying something your followers wouldn't expect. Megan on our team has tested them on and off for a couple of years, including for a hotel client. If the video is the same kind of thing you always post, a trial reel probably won't make much of a difference. Two lifestyle versions she tested for the hotel got 136 and 116 views, and she thinks they'd likely have done just as well posted straight to the feed.
Sprout Social's guide to trial reels says trends are worth testing in a "lower risk environment," since not every trend suits every brand. So I'd save trial reels for:
Here are a few tests you could run this month, depending on what you sell:
Views only tell you how far Instagram pushed the video. Shares tell you if strangers liked it enough to send it to someone. That's why Creatorflow suggests judging a trial on shares per view (shares divided by views).
Sprout also says to match the number to your goal. If you want awareness, views matter more. If you want people to interact, look at shares and comments. And from our own test, I'd add one more: watch how fast people swipe away in the first couple of seconds. That's where our crossword video lost everyone.
Take your first look at 24 hours, not the same day. SocialKit points out that checking too early doesn't give Instagram enough time to show it to people. Instagram's auto-share option then decides based on the first 72 hours.
But don't delete a slow one too fast. Megan has seen some trial reels slowly find their people after two and a half to four weeks. And Maggie on our team suggested a simple rhythm that I really like: post a reel as a trial, give it around two weeks, then push the winners to your main feed.
Three things our team learned the hard way:
Pick one reel this month where a real person is using your product. Add one clear line of text in the first second. Post it as a trial, check it at 24 hours, and look at the shares, not just the views. Even if it flops like my word search did, you'll know what to skip next time. 🙌🏼
.webp)
This guide is a step-by-step blueprint for consumer product brands looking to turn their happiest customers into powerful brand affiliates. By leveraging social media, brands can create a cost-effective, high-converting affiliate program that generates organic word-of-mouth marketing.
